The Cost of Dirty Money

Since the financial crisis, dozens of crackdowns have targeted money launderers who effectively rely on banks, shell companies, and other mechanisms to cover their tracks. Fines have surged into the billions of dollars, but it’s unclear whether the enforcement efforts—some of the more notable ones are described here—have made much of a dent. According to the United Nations Office on Drugs and Crime, shady transactions continue to reach as much as $2 trillion a year.

Bank Other

JPMorgan Chase

NEW YORK

ING

AMSTERDAM

Danske Bank

COPENHAGEN

Citigroup

NEW YORK

Commerzbank

FRANKFURT

Deutsche Bank

FRANKFURT

HSBC

LONDON

Wachovia

CHARLOTTE

Standard Chartered

LONDON

Bangladesh

Hackers

DHAKA

Liberty

Reserve

COSTA RICA

1MDB

KUALA LUMPUR

Teodoro Nguema

Obiang Mangue

MALABO

Commonwealth

Bank of Australia

SYDNEY

PDVSA

CARACAS

ING

AMSTERDAM

Danske Bank

COPENHAGEN

JPMorgan Chase

NEW YORK

Commerzbank

FRANKFURT

Citigroup

NEW YORK

Deutsche Bank

FRANKFURT

HSBC

LONDON

Wachovia

CHARLOTTE

Standard Chartered

LONDON

Bangladesh

Hackers

DHAKA

1MDB

KUALA LUMPUR

Liberty

Reserve

COSTA RICA

Teodoro Nguema

Obiang Mangue

MALABO

Commonwealth

Bank of Australia

SYDNEY

PDVSA

CARACAS

JPMorgan

Chase

NEW YORK

ING

AMSTERDAM

Danske Bank

COPENHAGEN

Commerzbank

FRANKFURT

Citigroup

NEW YORK

Deutsche Bank

FRANKFURT

Wachovia

CHARLOTTE

HSBC

LONDON

Standard

Chartered

LONDON

Bangladesh

Hackers

DHAKA

Liberty

Reserve

COSTA RICA

1MDB

KUALA LUMPUR

PDVSA

CARACAS

Teodoro Nguema

Obiang Mangue

MALABO

Commonwealth

Bank of Australia

SYDNEY

JPMorgan

Chase

NEW YORK

ING

AMSTERDAM

Danske Bank

COPENHAGEN

Commerzbank

FRANKFURT

Citigroup

NEW YORK

Deutsche Bank

FRANKFURT

HSBC

LONDON

Wachovia

CHARLOTTE

Standard

Chartered

LONDON

Bangladesh

Hackers

DHAKA

Liberty

Reserve

COSTA RICA

Teodoro Nguema

Obiang Mangue

MALABO

1MDB

KUALA LUMPUR

PDVSA

CARACAS

Commonwealth

Bank of Australia

SYDNEY

JP Morgan

Chase

Danske Bank

ING

Commerzbank

Citigroup

Deutsche Bank

HSBC

Standard

Chartered

Wachovia

Bangladesh

Hackers

Liberty

Reserve

1MDB

PDVSA

Commonwealth

Bank of Australia

Teodoro Nguema

Obiang Mangue

JPMorgan

Chase

Danske Bank

ING

Commerzbank

Citigroup

Deutsche Bank

HSBC

Wachovia

Standard

Chartered

Bangladesh

Hackers

Liberty

Reserve

1MDB

PDVSA

Commonwealth

Bank of Australia

Teodoro Nguema

Obiang Mangue

Citigroup
FINE
$237m
From about 2007 until 2012, Banamex USA, a Citi subsidiary, processed more than $8.8 billion in transactions with almost no oversight. Citi was fined by the Federal Deposit Insurance Corp. and the California Department of Business Oversight in 2015. Two years later, it entered into a nonprosecution agreement with the U.S. Department of Justice.
JPMorgan Chase
FINE
$2.05b
For 15 years or so, according to a U.S. court settlement in 2014, JPMorgan ignored red flags surrounding the dealings of Wall Street financier Bernard Madoff, who used his account at the bank to run a $65 billion Ponzi scheme, the largest ever uncovered in the U.S.
Wachovia
FINE
$160m
Mexican drug cartels used accounts at Wachovia to finance their operations and launder money. From 2004 through 2007, the bank, since acquired by Wells Fargo, processed at least $373 billion in wire transfers from Mexican currency houses, according to a 2010 deferred prosecution agreement with U.S. authorities.
Liberty Reserve
The digital currency platform was central to an alleged $6 billion money laundering operation. In 2016, U.S. authorities sentenced its founder, Arthur Budovsky, to 20 years in prison for running a money laundering enterprise through the Costa Rica-based platform.
PDVSA
Former Julius Baer banker Matthias Krull was sentenced by a U.S. court to 10 years in prison in October for his role in helping to launder $1.2 billion embezzled from state-owned Petróleos de Venezuela SA. (The bank wasn’t accused of any wrongdoing.)
Standard Chartered
FINE
$967m
In 2012 the bank paid $667 million in fines for violating U.S. sanctions on doing business with Iran. In 2014, New York state fined it an additional $300 million for weak anti-money-laundering controls.
HSBC
FINE
$1.9b
The bank failed to monitor properly more than $670 billion in wire transfers from Mexico and more than $9.4 billion in purchases of U.S. currency, according to a 2012 deferred prosecution agreement with U.S. authorities. An elaborate system of deposits and money transfers allowed Mexican and Colombian drug cartels to launder their illicit proceeds.
Danske Bank
In September the bank said about €200 billion ($230 billion) in potentially illegal funds flowed through its tiny Estonian unit over nine years—despite warnings from a whistleblower and regulators. Investigations are under way in Denmark, Estonia, and the U.S.
ING
FINE
$900m
In a 2018 agreement with Dutch authorities, the bank acknowledged “serious shortcomings” in failing to prevent illicit payments by VimpelCom to a company owned by an Uzbek government official. VimpelCom, originally a Russian telecommunications company, is now called VEON.
Deutsche Bank
FINE
$670m
In 2017, U.S. and U.K. authorities fined the bank for a series of mirror trades conducted through its Moscow office. The trades allowed Russians to expatriate billions of dollars by buying stocks with rubles at home and selling the same shares in London for dollars or euros.
Commerzbank
FINE
$1.45b
From about 2002 to 2008, the bank processed more than $250 billion in transactions on behalf of Iranian and Sudanese entities. Because of ineffective compliance controls, according to a 2015 consent order with the New York Department of Financial Services, it failed to share relevant information with authorities about clients subject to U.S. sanctions.
Teodoro Nguema Obiang Mangue
The son of the president of Equatorial Guinea (and now the country’s vice president) made off with more than $300 million from the country from 2004 to 2011, via bribery, kickbacks, and money laundering, according to a 2014 U.S. settlement he signed. The U.S. seized about $30 million in assets, including Michael Jackson memorabilia and a Malibu mansion bought through a shell company.
Bangladesh Hackers
Hackers stole $81 million from the central bank of Bangladesh in 2016. The thieves used Swift, the global interbank payment system, to issue bogus instructions to withdraw Bangladesh Bank funds from the Federal Reserve Bank of New York—and then laundered it through Asian casinos.
1MDB
From 2009 through 2015, more than $4.5 billion flowed from this government fund into the hands of allegedly corrupt officials and their associates, according to a 2017 U.S. Department of Justice complaint. Malaysia filed criminal charges against Goldman Sachs, which arranged bond sales for 1MDB; the bank said it would “vigorously contest” the charges.
Commonwealth Bank of Australia
FINE
A$700m
In June, the bank paid the biggest civil penalty in Australian corporate history after admitting to more than 53,000 breaches of money laundering laws. The laundering allowed drug syndicates to funnel millions of dollars offshore.