Everything You Need to Know About Germany’s Complex Election Process

By Tony CzuczkaTony Czuczka, Hayley WarrenHayley Warren and Jana RandowJana Randow

After a tense contest in France and an upset in the U.K., German voters are heading to the polls to decide whether to give Chancellor Angela Merkel a fourth term. The leader of the EU’s dominant country faces Social Democrat Martin Schulz, among others, and should she win, will have to negotiate with other successful parties to create a governing coalition.

Here’s how voters will go about choosing the next German government.

Voting for Parliament

It’s more complex than in many other parliamentary democracies. Voters in 299 districts across Germany will cast a dual ballot on election day to pick members of the lower house of parliament, or Bundestag. The first vote elects the local representative, the second is for a party.

Main political parties

CDU/CSU

Christian Democratic Union

Christian Social Union (Bavaria)

SPD

Social Democratic Party

Greens

FDP

Free Democratic Party

Left

AfD

Alternative for Germany

First vote

For a local representative

SPD

Greens

FDP

Left

AfD

CDU

Second vote

For a party

SPD

Greens

FDP

Left

AfD

CDU

Main political parties

First vote

For a local representative

CDU/CSU

Christian Democratic Union

Christian Social Union (Bavaria)

SPD

SPD

Greens

FDP

Left

AfD

CDU

Social Democratic Party

Greens

Second vote

For a party

FDP

Free Democratic Party

Left

AfD

SPD

Greens

FDP

Left

AfD

CDU

Alternative for Germany

The second-vote result—as a percentage—is the main focus on election night because it determines the share of seats each party receives. Parties that take less than 5 percent nationwide (or fewer than three seats by direct election) are excluded, and the shares of the other parties is recalculated accordingly.

Each party apportions second-vote seats to its lawmakers by going down a list drafted by party officials. They join the directly-elected representatives in the Bundestag in Berlin. While Germany’s parliament has at least 598 members, the final number of seats isn’t fixed.

Here is what happened in the 2013 federal election.

First vote result

299 local representatives automatically

get a seat

Hamburg

Berlin

Munich

Second vote result

299 seats are filled proportionally from

16 regional lists

Votes, millions

10

5

1

First vote result

299 local representatives automatically get a seat

Second vote result

299 seats are filled proportionally from 16 regional lists

Hamburg

Berlin

Votes, millions

10

5

1

Munich

One thing to look out for is the allocation of extra Bundestag seats, which could decide which parties can form a coalition. When a party’s share of the local-representative vote exceeds its percentage of the party vote, that results in extra seats, known as overhang mandates. To avoid distorting the result of the party vote, other parties are then compensated with so-called leveling mandates. That’s why the Bundestag ballooned to 631 seats after the last election.

+16

+3

631

598

+3

+11

Additional seats

+16

631

598

+3

+3

+11

Additional seats

Forming a government and electing a chancellor

The party or bloc that takes the most seats has a mandate to form a government. If none has a majority, talks on forming a coalition ensue. Once a coalition agenda is agreed, the Bundestag elects the chancellor. After the last election in 2013, Merkel needed nine weeks to seal a coalition deal on policies and Cabinet posts.

Parliament elected

Chancellor

Angela Merkel

A grand coalition was formed between the CDU/CSU and SPD

Parliament elected

Chancellor

Angela Merkel

A grand coalition was formed between the CDU/CSU and SPD

If Merkel wins on Sept. 24, she’ll match former chancellors Konrad Adenauer and Helmut Kohl, both Christian Democrats like her, as the only leaders elected to four terms.

Germany’s Coalitions

1950

Konrad

Adenauer

1949-1963

’60

Social-liberal

coalition

SPD-FDP

’70

’80

Black-yellow

CDU/CSU-FDP

Helmut Kohl

1982-1998

’90

Red-green

SPD-GREEN

’00

Grand coalition

CDU/CSU-SPD

’10

Angela Merkel

2005-2017

Social-liberal coalition

SPD-FDP

Black-yellow coalition

CDU/CSU-FDP

Red-green coalition

SPD-GREEN

Grand coalition

CDU/CSU-SPD

1950

1970

1980

1990

2000

2010

1960

Konrad Adenauer

1949-1963

Helmut Kohl

1982-1998

Angela Merkel

2005-2017

Polls suggest Merkel is on track to win re-election, maintaining Germany as Europe’s pillar of stability. But with two additional parties expected to win seats in parliament, building a coalition government after the election may be more difficult than in the past.